
One of the most expensive mistakes I’ve made in business is trying to turn good employees into people they never wanted to become.
And sometimes, I was the reason they were struggling.
When we first start a business, we hire people who are willing to do just about anything.
They answer phones, handle customers, fix problems, and figure things out when there isn’t a process in sight.
They stay late. They wear five different hats. They help us survive.
And we become incredibly loyal to those people.
But then the business grows.
Suddenly, the person answering phones is managing the entire office.
The best cleaning technician becomes the trainer.
The person building the product is now responsible for leading the product team.
And when things start falling apart, we wonder what happened to that amazing employee.
Maybe nothing happened to them. Maybe you changed the job without changing the support, expectations, or skills required to succeed.
This Just Happened in My Own Company
Recently, Chris came to me and asked if I would take over leading our product team.
Chris is exceptional at building technology. He loves creating new features, solving technical problems, and improving LAYA.
But managing people, making department decisions, and holding everyone accountable were pulling him away from what he was exceptional at.
And our progress was slowing down.
I’ll admit, I was frustrated.
Why weren’t things getting done?
Why weren’t we hitting our goals?
Why was everything taking so long?
But instead of letting that frustration turn into resentment, we had an honest conversation.
Chris admitted something that wasn’t easy for him to say.
He didn’t want to lead the product team anymore.
He wanted to build.
And I stepped in to lead the department.
You know what happened?
The department started moving faster, and Chris could get back to doing what he does best.
We didn’t have a bad employee.
We didn’t even have a bad leader.
We had responsibilities sitting with the wrong person.
And the longer we avoided that conversation, the more expensive it became.
Loyalty Can Become a Leadership Trap
Here’s where I think business owners, especially those of us who lead with a lot of loyalty and personal connection, struggle.
We remember who helped us when we had nothing.
Who stayed late.
Who believed in us.
Who worked through the chaos.
And somewhere along the way, gratitude turns into obligation.
We feel like we owe them the next promotion, the next opportunity, or a permanent seat at the table.
But here’s something I had to learn:
You can be grateful for what someone helped you build without making them responsible for everything you build next.
Someone can be exceptional at helping a company reach $500,000 and struggle with what the company needs at $1 million.
That doesn’t erase their contribution.
It means the business has changed.
And before we decide they’ve become the problem, we need to look at what we’re asking them to do.
Before You Replace the Person, Examine the Role
At 1 Layer Deep®, I encourage owners to look at four things:
- Role: Has the job changed? Did you hire someone for customer service and gradually make them responsible for scheduling, payroll, hiring, and managing the office?
- Capability: Do they actually have the skills and capacity required today? Being your best salesperson doesn’t automatically make someone your best sales manager.
- Willingness: Do they want to grow into the position? Not everyone wants to manage people, and their actions will tell you more than their promises.
- Fit: After you’ve clarified expectations and provided reasonable support, is this still the right position for them?
That last question is usually the hardest.
Because sometimes the answer is no.
And sometimes, if we’re willing to admit it, the reason they’re struggling is that we never gave them what they needed to succeed.
We promoted them without training.
Added responsibilities without removing anything.
Expected leadership without teaching them how to lead.
Then got frustrated when they couldn’t figure it out.
That’s not an employee problem.
That’s a leadership problem.
The Cost of Avoiding the Conversation
Here’s what happens when we don’t address these situations.
The employee knows they’re struggling.
The team knows something isn’t working.
The owner feels the frustration.
But nobody wants to say anything because everyone likes each other.
So we wait.
Performance slips. Decisions get delayed. Other employees start picking up the slack.
Eventually, the frustration becomes so big that a conversation that could have saved the relationship turns into a termination.
Avoiding a difficult conversation doesn’t protect the relationship. Sometimes it’s exactly what destroys it.
And that’s what I want business owners to understand.
You don’t have to wait until you’re angry to make a change.
You can have the conversation while you still respect each other.
You can redesign a role.
You can provide training.
You can let someone return to the work they’re exceptional at.
And yes, sometimes you have to help them make a respectful transition out of the company.
But those decisions should come from clarity, not guilt or resentment.
Leadership ROI Review System
If you’re questioning whether someone on your leadership team is still in the right role, don’t make that decision based on how long they’ve worked for you or how frustrated you feel today.
Use our 1 Layer Deep® Leadership ROI Review System to evaluate whether a leadership position is delivering the results your business needs.
It helps you examine the value of a leadership seat and determine whether it needs more support, a change in responsibilities, or a different person.
ACCESS THE LEADERSHIP ROI REVIEW SYSTEM →
Stop Confusing Promotion With Progress
One of the biggest lessons from this week’s Q&A was that not everyone wants to become a leader.
And that’s okay.
Some people want to show up, do exceptional work, and go home.
They don’t want to manage employees.
They don’t want to make decisions for an entire department.
They don’t want the stress that comes with the next title.
And we need those people, too.
Because a business full of managers with nobody exceptional at doing the work isn’t much of a business.
So before you promote your best employee, ask whether they actually want the job.
Before you replace someone who’s struggling, ask whether you’ve put them in the right role.
And before you hold on to someone out of loyalty, ask whether staying is helping them succeed.
Your business can outgrow a role without outgrowing the person who once filled it.
Sometimes the greatest thing you can do for someone is give them room to grow.
Sometimes it’s giving them permission to stop growing in a direction they never wanted.
And sometimes it’s having the courage to recognize that the company and the person need different things.
Being loyal doesn’t mean keeping people in roles where they can’t succeed.
It means caring enough to make the right decision, even when that decision is uncomfortable.
Less layers. More results.
Stay In The Loop
Get one insight each week on hiring, systems, and clarity.
Build a business that works without you in every layer..
Join the private 1 Layer Deep™ Operators Facebook group for service-based business owners who want simpler systems, clearer execution, and less chaos inside the business.
See how owners are applying 1 Layer Deep™ using LAYA, microplays, gameplans, and real-world examples.